Every day I look at PokeBeach to see the latest news in the world of Pokémon. In particular, I pay attention to new trading card game products to see which ones I will consider parting with my hard earned money for. One of the first things I look at with these new promotional tins and collection boxes is the pack selection. After all, a product's value is determined by the quality of its contents.
I've been disappointed with several products lately due to their inclusion of the XY Evolutions expansion set. It has to be one of the worst sets of the XY series, and perhaps one of the worst sets period. Many forum users and popular Youtubers have expressed their displeasure for the set for multiple reasons. Evolutions represents a huge missed opportunity to end what was arguably one of the best eras of the entire Pokémon Trading Card Game.
XY Evolutions was meant to be a remake of the original Base Set which was released in Japan on October 20, 1996 and in the United States on January 9, 1999. Vintage artwork is used for the cards, while the attacks and effects have been modified to fit within the current format.
The main complaint against Evolutions centers on the cards themselves not being very competitive. A few cards have some potential to work in existing deck archetypes, but none of them brought any game changing mechanics to the table. According to Andrew Wamboldt of the Charizard Lounge, this was due to Pokémon themselves not wanting to shake things up too much just prior to the release of the next generation Sun & Moon base set, which would introduce powerful Pokémon-GX to the meta game. Evolutions' main purpose was to satisfy collectors who remember opening Base Set packs two decades ago - which brings me to the next point.
The entire year of 2016 was marked with promotional products to celebrate the twentieth year of the Pokémon franchise. A TV spot was shown during the Super Bowl, various legendary Pokémon were distributed to video game players throughout the year, and collection boxes containing trading cards from a special set called Generations were released each month.
Generations contained reprinted cards from XY era expansions with the stipulation that all the Pokémon featured had to be from the first generation. Exceptions to this rule were Meowstic-EX, and cards from the Radiant Collection subset. So when Evolutions came out in November 2016, it felt like we had already seen it before. Not only that, cards included in Generations were actually playable in several different decks, and pull rates for ultra rare cards were usually pretty good.
Hopefully, with the release of the fourth Sun & Moon set, the number of Evolutions packs included in products will decrease. It simply had no business being a mainline set. Making Evolutions a mini set would have been a much better choice for both collectors and players. That way, those who aren't caught up in Base Set nostalgia can purchase the products they want without having this otherwise useless set shoved down their throats. There also should have been some differentiation between Evolutions and Generations. It's rather hypocritical for a set called Generations to focus only on one particular generation of Pokémon.
I just hope that Pokémon comes up with a better way to end Sun & Moon when the time comes. Usually, each series concludes with a greatest hits collection featuring new artwork for popular cards. That was the case for Call of Legends and Legendary Treasures at the end of Gen 4 and Gen 5 respectively. Evolutions was a rare misstep for a franchise that otherwise had every reason to celebrate 20 successful years, and several more to follow.
No comments:
Post a Comment